Home Blog Mountain Grandeur and the Authority of Numbers

Mountain Grandeur and the Authority of Numbers

On September 23, 2026, CEVIHE’s Politics and Culture from All Sides lunch series explored whether the grandeur of a mountain can be measured. Solly Coles, Norbert Wiener Fellow in the Department of Mathematics at Tufts University, led the discussion of Gordy Megroz’s article “Have We Been Measuring Mountains All Wrong?” (National Geographic, September 16, 2025). The reading let students, faculty, and staff trace how one person’s experience of awe became a formula, then a public ranking that helped other people decide where to travel.

When a student crosses a college off a list because of its rank, the people who designed the ranking have had a say in where that student might spend the next four years. A living-wage estimate carries a different kind of authority. Before anyone calculates a dollar amount, someone must decide whose household the wage should support. In both cases, people can agree on the arithmetic and still have good reason to question what the number is being asked to decide.

Coles began with the familiar practice of measuring elevation above sea level. A hiker who wants to know how far a trail climbs needs a different starting point. Yet that same hiker has good reason to care about altitude when preparing for the thinner air near the summit. Whether a measurement is wrong, Coles observed, “depends on what you were trying to do.”

Looking up from California’s Owens Valley, Kai Xu wanted to understand why the eastern Sierra Nevada seemed so imposing. His formula combines a summit’s vertical rise above a given point with the angle at which an observer there would have to look up. The largest value across all viewpoints is the mountain’s “jut.” Colorado’s Mount Elbert stands higher above sea level than Wyoming’s Grand Teton, yet Grand Teton has more than twice its jut. A traveler hoping to stand beneath a towering mountain face might reasonably choose the lower peak.

Coles drew attention to the choice of that maximum. Why should a single extraordinary viewpoint determine a mountain’s standing if no hiker can reach it? An average along a trail would tell hikers more about the views they are likely to encounter. The distinction matters even to someone who never plans to hike. Anyone reading a list of mountains ranked by grandeur encounters a judgment about which experience counts, whether or not the list discloses it. As Coles asked, “Why am I making these choices? And who do the choices serve?”

Professor Eitan Hersh recalled visiting Grand Teton with his children. Xu’s work helped him articulate what had caught his eye. “But why does it look nice? What do you mean by nice?” he asked. He also wondered how knowing the score in advance might change the outing itself. A hiker might trade the climb to the summit for the spot in the valley that yields the best photograph. Indeed, Megroz reported that some hikers had already changed their travel plans after learning about jut.

Students saw a case for adding measures. In baseball, a pitcher who commands the corners of the strike zone can succeed against the same hitters as one with an overpowering fastball. Measuring both control and velocity gives fans more ways to recognize excellence. Jut could do something similar for a mountain that few people would notice on a list organized by elevation alone.

The difficulty arises when many individually sensible decisions begin to narrow the range of experiences people share. A viewer with one free evening has good reason to consult a film rating. But if a whole generation of viewers sticks to the same list, who will discover a neglected film worth recommending? Participants extended that concern to the arts themselves. A writer who wanders onto an unremarkable trail may notice something that would escape a crowd assembled at the designated viewpoint. What might go unwritten if every aspiring writer takes the highest-rated trail?

Popularity also has consequences for people who never consult the list. Hersh recalled visitors stepping off tour buses at Sequoia National Park and passing other enormous trees to see the one identified as the largest. Megroz saw a promise in directing travelers to peaks familiar chiefly to nearby communities. Students asked what that discovery looks like to the people who already know the place. Travelers gain a new destination. Residents may inherit the work of caring for a suddenly crowded trail.

Coles put a question of responsibility to the group. What does someone who devises a measure owe the people who will rely on it? Consider his example of a living wage. Two analysts can agree on every local price and produce different figures because one budgets for a worker living alone and the other includes the cost of raising a child. A more precise survey of prices cannot resolve whose needs a wage ought to cover. Tracing Xu’s formula gave participants practice distinguishing a dispute about the evidence from a dispute about whose needs or preferences should count. In public debate, mistaking one for the other can leave the people most affected by a decision with little opportunity to challenge it. As Coles put it, “you always lose something when you turn something qualitative into something quantitative, and you need to tell people what you are losing.”

This event recap was prepared by CEVIHE, with reporting support from Devon Chang and photography by Cooper Kolehmainen.

2026_09_26_CEVIHE_Mountian_Lunch-2